Wednesday, February 4, 2026

Response to Commissioner Kamoutsas Regarding Student Protest and Authority

This is my response to the Letter from the Florida Department of Education about student walkouts, transcribed and linked below. I also sent a watered-down version to several superintendents across the state:
*****
    Our students are Americans before they are students. But do let us examine the laziness of this letter from Florida Commissioner of Education Kamoutsas. The letter’s purported goal is the utmost in educational atmosphere and achievement. And yet, the maintenance of authority is prioritized over critical thinking, reflection on values, nurturing independent thought, and observing society at work. Real-world learning is often more effective for fostering critical thinking, engagement, and long-term retention. While classroom learning provides a structured foundation in knowledge and discipline, real-world experiences develop practical skills, resilience, and confidence in navigating complex situations. True education instills a thirst for life-long learning. Control, not education, is the desired effect of this letter. 
    Mr. Kamoutsas speaks of protecting instructional time, when our students sit around doing nothing for days before a break and at the end of the school year, during various testing windows, and almost anytime a substitute teacher is present. Some sources report Florida as having the worst teacher pay of all 50 states, in a country with a teacher pay problem, and then the Commissioner presents this letter as though a few minutes in the classroom is so important, i.e., that what those severely underpaid teachers have to offer is so important, that it must come before even the expression of fundamental Constitutional rights. 
    We are a people who went to war to escape the control of authority. Now the Florida Department of Education wants to exert authority to the extent of preserving peace over practicing the expression that very war afforded to us. Being an American means, sometimes, dropping the daily routine and fighting for American rights. And the education found in that act of love and support of our fellows, in the spirit of the republic built by those who went to war to secure it, and with a connection to the reality of our forebears, would trump any day of school.  
    True education nurtures ethical values. This letter is not about what is best for students; it is about what is best for the ease of those in authority, exactly the thing we became Americans to escape. High-quality instruction would include lessons in standing up for our fellow man. Thoughtful, supportive educational leadership would seek to use students’ inclinations to listen to their intuition when it is screaming at them, something is wrong. Use this opportunity to teach students how to protest peacefully, and what to do with intense thoughts and feelings when they arise in the context of the American experience. Incendiary moments in American life will continue to happen. Our Florida educational system, by this letter, seeks to deprive our students of the direct academic relevance of the current political atmosphere and fails to show them how to connect theoretical knowledge with practical, messy, real-world problems.
    The Commissioner gives lip service in his letter to preserving high-quality instructional time, while failing to recognize the rich educational opportunity in the healthy desire of students to protest. True education teaches critical thinking.  A quality education system provides students the opportunity to actively analyze, synthesize, and evaluate information to guide belief and action. It involves objectively examining facts, questioning assumptions, and using reasoning to form sound judgments rather than accepting information at face value. Our children sit in classrooms because important moments in time do not present themselves on a daily basis, not because that is the better way to learn. The Commissioner appears to have forgotten what higher-quality instructional time and atmosphere actually looks like. 
    By this letter, it seems that Florida Public Schools wish to tell students to put their thoughts and feelings aside and go back to class. It wants no instruction provided. It wants to ignore reality. It throws away this real-life, first-hand opportunity to discuss what this country is, analyze what it stands for, and evaluate what our rights are as Americans. Some of those rights are called fundamental rights. They protect individual dignity, liberty, and equality against government overreach. Rather than treating fundamental constitutional rights with the respect and gravity they deserve, Mr. Kamoutsas seems to throw a bone to those ideas in the middle of the letter, buries the topic, and then moves on to the more pressing importance of maintaining classroom authority. Fundamental rights ensure a society based on the rule of law rather than authoritarian rule.
    We live in a free country . . . except, if you work at a school and help your students express and understand their own values and participate in American politics, you will be subject to discipline. Meaning, if you teach in Florida, you live in a country where you toe the line, or you won’t be able to pay your mortgage next month. You live in a country where you have to decide between free speech/expression and reputational management/fear of retaliation. That is not even the illusion of freedom. That is, at best, collective denial, and at worst, authoritarian rule.
    For administrators and teachers, what exactly constitutes “encouraging” participation in protest activity? If they teach about it at all, will teachers be subject to disciplinary action? Would helping students to express themselves, understand their own country, and learn about their rights by organizing a protest to occur at the final bell be a diversion from instruction? We all know the answer. This letter is a threat. Authority and status quo must be maintained at the expense of anything you, teachers, and students feel or think about participating in the American experiment. We can all see by this letter how the experiment is going.

*****

Here is a transcription of the Letter from the Florida Department of Education about student walkouts:

"The Florida Department of Education recently received correspondence from members of the Florida legislature regarding reports of organized student protest activity occurring during the school day. I want to thank them for bringing this matter to my attention and for their leadership in elevating concerns related to student safety, instructional time, and the appropriate role of public schools.
Florida’s public schools exist first and foremost to provide high-quality instruction aligned to state academic standards in a safe and secure environment. School district leaders and school-based administrators carry a responsibility to safeguard instructional time, maintain campus safety, and ensure compliance with law, State Board of Education rules, and local school board policy.
Students retain constitutional rights to free expression, including the ability to engage in peaceful protest, when such expression complies with applicable law and school district policy. Any student whose actions are to the contrary should be appropriately disciplined. Districts have a responsibility to ensure that any protest activity does not interrupt instructional time, school operations and campus safety.
Administrators and instructional staff must not encourage, organize, promote, or facilitate student participation in protest activity during the school day. Any conduct by school or district personnel that diverts students from instruction, undermines classroom authority, or compromises student supervision violates professional responsibilities and warrants disciplinary action. Moreover, Rule 6A-10.081, Florida Administrative Code, requires educators to take reasonable precautions to distinguish between personal views and those of any educational institution or organization with which the individual is affiliated. Administrators must take proactive steps to ensure students remain under appropriate supervision during school hours and that instructional environments remain safe and focused on learning.
Florida parents and families: instructional time matters. Classroom instruction provides students with the academic foundation they need to succeed, and schools must protect that time. While students may lawfully express their views in appropriate settings, Florida’s public schools must remain focused on teaching, learning, and student safety. Therefore, we encourage you to have conversations with your students about the importance of not allowing civic engagement to detract from time in the classroom.
Superintendents: I expect you to share this communication with district leadership, school administrators, teachers and parents. I further expect that you address any violations of policy, by either students or staff, promptly and appropriately.

Thank you to all who share the responsibility of keeping Florida schools focused on education and student safety: teachers, administrators, parents, school resource officers, school guardians, and law enforcement partners."

Here is a link to Letter:  Department of Ed Letter.jpg

No comments:

Post a Comment